The Trump administration on Friday finalized changes to sweeping federal land use plans for the west, easing restrictions on energy companies and other industries in a way officials said would still protect a struggling bird species.
But environmentalists said the widely-anticipated move will undermine protections for the chicken-sized grouse. It would allow more oil and gas drilling, mining and other activities that can disrupt grouse breeding grounds.
Tracy Stone Manning of the National Wildlife Federation said the Trump administration has focused “not on conserving the species across the landscape but instead on supporting more energy development”, which is a main threat to the sage grouse.
“We’re concerned that years of work is going to come undone, and we’re concerned these plans have now set up a dynamic where the states are going to have to do the hard work of ensuring that the bird doesn’t get listed [under the Endangered Species Act]”, she said.
The changes by the US Bureau of Land Management (BLM) will guide future efforts to conserve greater sage grouse, ground-dwelling birds that range across portions of 11 western states.
The changes secured key backing from Democratic and Republican governors in affected states, bolstering the administration’s position that revisions were needed to plans crafted under Barack Obama.
Kate Brown, the Democratic governor of Oregon, said in a statement that the changes marked “a shift away from planning toward active conservation and landscape management”.
The birds are known for an elaborate mating ritual in which males fan their tails and puff out yellow air sacs in their chests as they strut around breeding grounds. Their numbers have plummeted due to energy development, disease and other factors.
Opponents are expected to challenge the changes in court. Brian Rutledge with the Audubon Society said the revisions will make it harder to stop the long-term decline of sage grouse by giving oil and gas companies access to crucial grouse habitat. “It’s a free for all, based on prioritizing fossil fuel extraction over any other use of the federal landscape,” Rutledge said.
The chairman of the US House natural resources committee, the Arizona Democrat congressman Raul Grijalva, said the changes would benefit former clients of the acting interior secretary, David Bernhardt. Bernhardt worked as an oil and gas industry lobbyist before joining the Trump administration.
Grijalva in a statement called the administration’s decision “a smash-and-grab-job on our environment”.
The Bureau of Land Management acting director, Brian Steed, told the Associated Press the changes address concerns aired by state officials that previous policies governing millions of acres of federal land were too restrictive. Those policies had been memorialized in a 2015 partnership between Western states and the federal government, but officials from several states had since sought changes.
Steed said the broad revisions to the Obama-era plans were meant to move beyond what he called a “one-size-fits-all” approach under the old rules. He said they give more flexibility to land managers and states concerned about balancing economic development with protections for the bird.
“Our intent was not to throw out the plans, but to make them better respond to the needs on the ground,” Steed said. “We’re doing that in a very careful way to ensure that the bird’s protections are still in effect.”
Sage grouse once numbered in the millions but the most recent estimates from the US Fish and Wildlife Service place the population at between 200,000 and 500,000.
The 2015 plans capped years of negotiations and were intended to prevent the bird from being designated a threatened or endangered species. That status could have brought severe limitations on grazing, energy development and other activities across the bird’s range, which covers some 270,000 sq miles (700,000 sq km).
Under Donald Trump, interior department officials have vowed to lift obstacles to drilling. Grouse protections have long been viewed by the energy industry as an obstacle to development.
The new plans were expected to remove the most protective habitat designations for about 13,000 sq miles (34,000 sq km) of public land. Those areas, considered essential to the species’ survival, were a centerpiece of the Obama policy.
The Trump administration also would drop some requirements to prioritize leasing for oil and gas outside sage grouse habitat and allow for more waivers for drilling. In Wyoming, one of the most important remaining strongholds for the species, the Republican governor Mark Gordon said the changes would help economic development while conserving grouse.
Utah’s Republican governor Gary Herbert said the BLM’s new approach “will really compliment what we’re already doing. That’s good news for how we manage sage grouse population in the state of Utah.”